Gyms in Eltingville, NYC

Compare membership prices for 2 gyms in Eltingville, NYC. See all-in monthly costs including fees, plus day passes, side by side.

Prices from each gym's own website, as of August 27, 2026 · How we collect data →

Compare gym prices in Eltingville, NYC

• Rare Breed Fitness - Rare Breed Compound — $72/mo all-in · Eltingville
• Rare Breed Fitness Club — $85/mo all-in · Eltingville

Similar gyms nearby

• YMCA - South Shore — $79/mo · 0.1 mi away
• Club Pilates Staten Island — $289/mo · 2.7 mi away
• Team Real USA — $30/mo · 2.7 mi away
• Club Pilates New Dorp — $289/mo · 3.1 mi away
• Retro Fitness - New Springville — $40/mo · 3.1 mi away
• Crunch Fitness - Staten Island South — $39/mo · 3.3 mi away

Nearby neighborhoods: Upper East Side · Upper West Side · Chelsea · Midtown · Williamsburg · Long Island City